The Numbers Saga

Numbers Can Lie

Two stores' worth of warranty repairs land on one store, same quota, same budget. The numbers rewarded the cheaters, and everybody could see it.

Layout

People who say numbers don’t lie never had to pull the numbers themselves. I’ve written about that before. Reading the trees and missing the forest. Last time the bad numbers hid a good story. This time the good numbers hid the truth.

The back room was closed

A couple weeks ago I wrote about turning a repair center around. Bottom of the company to a top 25 performer. Closed the back room. Got the techs on the floor. Went from 525 to 22 in three months and hung there.

Ran good for about four months.

Then Sprint hit financial trouble. They decided to close half of all service and repair stores.

I keep trying to figure out what went into that calculation. Nobody told me. But my store was a top performer, and the other store was near the bottom. If you’re cutting half and keeping half, that should be easy math.

They closed mine.


They called it a layoff

They laid off my staff. Training a crew up, getting them to where customers loved coming in, then handing them a pink slip.

They also let go of the lead tech at the other store. A guy I’d never met. Someone the techs there had worked with and liked.

Then they moved me into his place.

I walked in cold. To say it was a challenge is an understatement.


The same playbook, different dirt

I did the same things that worked the first time. Progress, but slow. Not a quick turnaround, and I knew why.

The culture came from the top. Sprint cared about sales. Everybody knew that. Sales is what makes money. Service and repair was a cost center, so that’s what leadership ran and the repair floor paid for it. The focus wasn’t the problem. The problem was the focus came at the cost of everything else. And a number that sacred is going to find someone willing to lie for it.

Every time I wanted to eat a little pain up front to fix something, they resisted. Immediate satisfaction over delayed gratification. I could not get that mindset to change.

One tech had been there forever, set in her ways. Nothing I did or said mattered. I had no backing from leadership. They didn’t care that I had already run a successful store.

The quota didn’t help.


The LG phone

Here’s the thing about a warranty exchange. It’s not a target. It’s a budget. In sales, higher is better. In warranty exchanges, lower is better. An exchange is what you do when you can’t fix it. The repair failed, so you swap the whole unit. Swaps are the expensive option. Every one eats the budget. Go over, and you’ve cost the company money. It also lands on you.

The LG G4 had a known defect. A bootloop. LG finally admitted it was a manufacturing fault, a loose contact between components. Faulty soldering on a connector on the main board. Not software. LG called it a loose contact between components. A bad solder joint that bricked the phone. You couldn’t fix it. You couldn’t flash past it. The only resolution was a warranty exchange.

And every one of those counted against my budget.

LG didn’t give us the parts to fix it either. The G4’s board wasn’t among the components they supplied for repairs. Samsung was the best back then. They actually seemed to care about fixing the customer’s device. LG? Not so much.

A customer came in one day. Her son’s phone. It was destroyed. Cracked glass, back cover half broken off, swollen battery, water damage indicators tripped. It wouldn’t even turn on. It wasn’t bootlooping. It was physically dead.

She wanted a warranty replacement. Because of the known issue.

I denied it. Not because I wouldn’t have fixed it. There was no repair in my power. The known issue didn’t apply to a phone that was drowned and beaten. She didn’t like that answer. She went to the assistant store manager. He didn’t back me.

Just go ahead and replace it.

I said it’s not bootlooping. It won’t even turn on.

He said, yeah, but there’s a known issue.

It didn’t matter. I didn’t make that exchange willingly. The policy said this phone didn’t qualify for the known issue. The ASM didn’t care. He outranked me, and it went through.

It cost the store nothing. They aren’t graded hard on repair stats. It cost me one of my warranty allowances. One I shouldn’t have had to spend at all.


The quota trap

When they closed my store, they cut the service and repair capacity in my metro in half. Two stores’ worth of warranty demand, landing on one store. Same quota. Same allowance.

Two stores had become one, and the budget never moved.

Every exchange cost double what it used to. The G4 failures still counted. No grace.

I climbed out of the bottom quintile. Fourth. Then third. Progress, slow, and I thought the grading was unfair. I was doing the work, and the number kept punishing me.

Then I noticed something else. Stores in similar or smaller markets had higher quotas than we did. Higher allowances. And they were hitting them.

Mine wasn’t. The gap didn’t add up.


Numbers can lie

So I went digging. One nice thing about the role: I could pull records from any store. Sales records, repair tickets, receipts, whatever I wanted.

The first store I looked at had a pattern. Any time there was a sale, the next day there was a quick fix on that exact same phone. Same account number. Every single time.

Here’s what that meant. The sales rep finished the sale, printed the receipt, handed it to the tech. The tech hung onto it until the next day, then filed a quick fix.

No customer came in for that quick fix. No door swing. It was a ghost.

If they’d filed it the day of the sale, it would have been the same customer visit and counted for nothing. Holding the receipt overnight turned one customer into two. A sale, and a phantom repair visit. Every ghost quick fix added to their repair traffic. Made it look like they did way more than they did.

Next two or three stores. Same exact pattern.

And some of those stores were sitting on top of the leaderboard. Top performers. The same way I’d been at my first store.

I found the receipts. Every last one. Literally.

When your employees are a number, don’t be surprised when your systems and your business are too.


The toe-to-toe

The night before the regional supervisor’s visit, I sat down with my repair team and showed them everything. They asked if I was sure I wanted to go toe-to-toe.

I had everything behind me. Yes.

The supervisor did his walkthrough. I waited for my shot. Then we sat down. Him, me, and my store manager. He started hammering our performance.

I had the stack of papers in my hand. Ready to throw down.

My store manager started crying. Not a little. Bawling. Uncontrollably. She said she hadn’t been in this world that long. She didn’t know how to handle service and repair.

He went from hammering us to comforting her in one breath. Oh, it’s okay. Not a big deal. We’ll work through this.

Then they both left.

I sat there with the receipts. All that work. Nobody saw a single page. She started crying, so nobody worried about it.


The honest contrast

I kept doing the job. Good customer service, best I could do. The other tech there was genuinely good. He took everything I said, took the criticism, learned. There was almost nothing the two of us couldn’t fix. He even got featured in a JerryRigEverything video once for something he did.

We’re still friends. He calls me the best boss he ever had.

The second turnaround worked. Not as high as the first. What held it back wasn’t the work. It was the leadership above me.


The same disease

Sprint wanted repair traffic. So the stores filed phantom quick fixes and turned one customer into two. The traffic looked real. The metric rewarded fake.

Different companies. Different floors. Same disease both times.

When a number stops measuring the outcome, employees chase the number. Every time. Not because it’s right. Because it’s the number. That isn’t a failure of character. It’s a failure of design. You don’t blame people for playing the game by the rules you set up. You fix the game.


The small world

Wireless is a big world, and also a small one.

I showed up. I did the work. The receipts were right, and the moment got stolen before anyone saw them. That’s the part that sits with you.

But I never stopped doing the real job. Because of how well I did, Samsung noticed. They poached me to help train AT&T call centers in a pilot program. That got my foot in the door as a contractor.

The numbers lied. The scoreboard rewarded the cheaters. But the work didn’t lie, and the people watching the work noticed.

So do the real job anyway. Not because the scoreboard will fix itself. Because the work is what outlasts it. And when somebody finally asks for the receipts, yours will be the only ones that check out.

That’s where the next story starts.

End · Numbers Can Lie